Michael Milton

Michael Milton and Faith for Living, Inc.

  • Communication
    • Sermons
    • Books
      • Sounding the Depths
      • Silent No More
      • Hit by Friendly Fire
      • Songs in the Night
      • What is the Doctrine of Adoption?
      • Small Things, Big Things
      • What God Starts, God Completes
      • Previous Books
    • Music
      • When Heaven Came Down
      • Through the Open Door
      • Follow Your Call
      • He Shall Restore
    • Resources
      • Commentaries
      • Letters to Our Students
      • Links
      • Faith for Living Podcasts
    • Special Offer
  • Discipleship
  • Education
    • DJK Institute
  • About
    • Biography
    • Press Kit
  • Giving

February 17, 2020

How to Write a Discussion Board Post for Seminary (and graduate school)

“Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth” (2 Timothy 2:15 KJV).

One of the most crucial weekly learning activities is the Online Discussion Board Posts. Discussion Board Posts allow for peer-to-peer classroom interaction, as well as faculty responses. These responses serve as essential instances of guiding, answering questions, and commenting on progress.

In a Discussion Board Posting assignment, students are given a “prompt.” You respond with scholarly writing of at least 100-200 words. Cite your references. List your references. Then, you respond to each other, at least two others in the class (unless the course is too small to accomplish more than one peer-response). The first posts should be performed by midnight on Thursday at midnight. Responses to other students in the class should happen by Saturday night at midnight. This standard allows time to research and articulate your response and, then, have time to view others. Because of the nature of the postings and their relationship to class interaction, posts made before the module week or after are merely ineffective. Initial postings and responses must happen in the same module. Students who post after Thursday and respond to others after Saturday will lose ten points in their posts for that modular week.

How to Write the Online Discussion Board Post and Response

In writing the initial post, write with a scholarly voice. Respond to the question by demonstrating mastery of the materials for that week. It may be that the professor asks an item that is outside of the materials for a given module. In that case, the student must recognize the challenge and initiate a campaign of research to find the answer. This, too, is part of the Seminary experience. Research is vital in pastoral ministry and other expressions of a ministerial vocation.

Write a response of 100-200 words using the IDEA method of Online Discussion Board Postings (see below: “Writing A Substantive Discussion Post For An Online Class Forum,” Pateete, 2020).

Online Discussion Board ResponsesDownload

Cite your references in-line (not the standard way to cite in Turabian. See “A word on using Turabian in Discussion Board Posts” below. List references cite in Turabian-Chicago style after the posting (whether the initial posting or a response to a fellow student).

Further Notes on Writing Posts

Be careful to avoid the tendency to merely applaud your colleagues. While applause is preferable to berating something that a colleague composes—which is not allowed—it is much better to write with a “scholarly voice.” A scholarly voice is demonstrated by critical thinking, theological reflection, and application. This also means that you write as a theological student engaging ideas (not persons) with assertions that are grounded in a sound source (e.g., Scripture, peer-reviewed journal article, book, etc.).

Some have even argued for a division of labor to accomplish school projects (Doniger 1999, 65). The posting continues for about 150 words.

References

(Note that the formatting for a Turabian bibliographic entry cannot be imported; no problem for discussion board posts, but that is not okay for research papers)

Doniger, Wendy. 1999. Splitting the difference. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Using Turabian in Discussion Board Posts

Turabian style does not usually use in-line text citations. Instead, Turabian utilizes footnotes to cite material. The problem with Online Discussion Board Posts is that most Learning Management Systems (e.g., Brightspace) do not allow for references in the Discussion Board posting space. So, what to do? Utilize the Turabian-Chicago “in-line” alternative ONLY IN THE DISCUSSION BOARD posts (go here for further help in Turabian in-line citations). Continue to use the ordinary way of citing via footnotes. So, in Turabian, a citation in a Discussion board, without the ability to footnote, would look like this (this is fictional):

Single book author (Gerahty 2019, 15)
More than one author (Call and Capwell 2015, 15-21)
More than four authors (Larsen et al. 2010, 521)

Here is an excerpt from one of the resources below:

“Remember The Acronym ‘IDEA’ When You Write A Forum Post” (Patete, 2016)
As you are writing a substantive post for your forum, remember the acronym “IDEA.” IDEA consists of four concepts (I have added a distinctively theological way of interpreting these steps):

Identify, Interpret, or Infer the principle being learned. LOCATE THE PRESENTING ISSUE.

Define and Dissect the principle being studied. C: move from the issue to a Biblical-theological perspective.

Explore and Explain the principle being studied and how you think it applies to the discussion forum. CRITICAL THINKING 2.

Analyze the concept being discussed, Apply it to a fact pattern, and Advocate a position or recommendation.” THEOLOGICAL REFLECTION (see Milton, “What is the Difference between Critical Thinking and Theological Reflection?” 2018).

EXAMPLE: DISCUSSION BOARD POSTING USING TURABIAN IN-LINE

Maggie, I appreciate the way that you handled the issue of God’s sovereignty and human suffering. You did so with both theological insight and human compassion. We all agree that the question of theodicy is a challenge to both believers and those looking from the “outside-in.” Indeed, it is often a hurdle to coming to faith. One Catholic writer would get some “amens” from the Protestant corner of the Church, as well:

“The existence of suffering in a world created by a good and almighty God — ‘the problem of pain’ — is a fundamental theological dilemma, and perhaps the most serious objection to the Christian religion” (Bacz, C.S. Lewis’ Problem of Pain, 2020).

Reference
Patete, Dr. Anthony. 2016. “Writing A Substantive Discussion Post For An Online Class Forum.” Online Learning Tips. https://onlinelearningtips.com/2016/12/post-online-class-forum/.

Conclusion

The Discussion Board Posting is a critical part of your online learning experience. Once you master the basics of formatting, you can begin to move through the process of critical thinking and theological reflection quite quickly. What is the presenting issue? What are the underlying issues? What does God say about this? Resolve, apply, and close.

The truth is: the Discussion Board Posting is not only a way to generate “deeper learning” in your course work, but to also begin to build disciplines that will be needed for the rest of your career as a Gospel minister.

Resources: [Note: Bibliographic entries will not usually keep the original formatting; no problem for Discussion Board Posts)

  • Bennett College. “Turabian Style: In-Text (Parenthetical) Citations & Reference List – Holgate Library Research Guides.” Turabian Style: In-Text (Parenthetical) Citations & Reference List. Last modified 2012. Accessed February 16, 2020. http://libraryguides.bennett.edu/home/writing/chicago-turabian-style/turabian-style-in-text-parenthetical-citations–reference-list.
  • Jacek, Bacz. “C.S. Lewis: The Problem of Pain.” Accessed February 16, 2020. https://www.catholiceducation.org/en/religion-and-philosophy/apologetics/c-s-lewis-the-problem-of-pain.html.
  • Milton, Michael A. “The Difference between Theological Reflection and Critical Thinking.” Faith for Living, Inc., January 15, 2018. Accessed February 16, 2020. https://michaelmilton.org/2018/01/15/the-difference-between-theological-reflection-and-critical-thinking/.
  • ———. “The Five Habits of Highly Successful Online Graduate Students.” Michael Milton, April 11, 2018. Accessed February 16, 2020. https://michaelmilton.org/2018/04/11/the-five-habits-of-highly-successful-online-graduate-students/.
  • Patete, Anthony. “Writing A Substantive Discussion Post for An Online Class Forum.” Online Learning Tips, December 15, 2016. Accessed February 17, 2020. https://onlinelearningtips.com/2016/12/post-online-class-forum/.
  • “Discussion Rubrics.” Teaching Online Pedagogical Repository, n.d. Accessed February 16, 2020. https://topr.online.ucf.edu/discussion-rubrics/.
  • “Guidelines for Posting to Discussion Boards.” The Writing Center. Accessed February 16, 2020. https://writingcenter.gmu.edu/guides/guidelines-for-posting-to-discussion-boards.
  • “Sample Discussion Post.Pdf,” n.d. Accessed February 16, 2020. https://writingcenter.ashford.edu/sites/default/files/inline-files/Sample%20Discussion%20Post.pdf.
  • “Turabian Style Quick-Guide.” The Writing Center. Accessed February 16, 2020. https://writingcenter.gmu.edu/guides/turabian-style-quick-guide.

Podcast

Faith For Living
Faith For Living

Commited to spreading the Gospel of Jesus Christ.

Loving Fellowship
byDr. Michael Milton

Faith For Living with Dr. Michael Milton
March 21, 2023
– A study from Acts 28:11-16.


https://accradio.com/programs/erskinefaithforliving/faithforliving031423.mp3

Download (Right-Click To Save)

Loving Fellowship
Loving Fellowship
March 21, 2023
Dr. Michael Milton
Search Results placeholder

Subscribe. Follow. Listen.

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • apple-podcasts
Sign Up for Our Newsletter!

What is Faith For Living?

Faith for Living is the 501c3 North Carolina non-profit ministry of the Rev. Michael A. Milton, Ph.D. that exists to advance the Gospel of Jesus Christ to as many people as possible, through every means available, so that there will be a multitude caught up to be with Jesus Christ when He comes again. Faith for Living reaches out to support individuals, the Church, and other non-profits through communication, discipleship, and education.

Featured Music of Michael Milton

“Christ is Risen” words & music by Michael Anthony Milton
© 1999, 2012, 2020, 2021 Bethesda Music (a div. of Faith for Living, Inc.) | BMI | CCLI

Featured Book

“When your heart is broken, when your spirit is so crushed that you wonder if you will live again; when your life is in a total blackout; then, this book will give you the light and strength you need to carry on.”

—Russell, Amazon Reviews.

Songs in the Night is available in paperback and Kindle. Songs in the Night: How God Transforms Our Pain to Praise is NOW AVAILABLE in  Audiobook on AUDIBLE. Click here to purchase now.

This website is licensed under a Creative Commons License · Web design, development, and hosting by Five More Talents