Bach’s Fugue, Bonhoeffer’s Fragments, and the Prelude to Living: A Reformation Sunday Devotion

PipeOrganBefore Thy Throne I Now Appear

It was 1750. There is a story, thought to be apocryphal by some, yet confirmed by others,[1] that as the great Johann Sebastian Bach[2] lay dying he dictated the music of his final great work, a chorale prelude, to his sons. Bach’s second son, Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach, even made an annotation in the original manuscript to the death of his father.[3] Whether it was literally dictated, as he neared death, or he reworked and completed an earlier effort, musical scholars agree that the piece was his last. He named this short liturgical composition, “Vor deinen Thron tret ich heirmit “ (“Before Thy Throne I now appear”):

Before your throne I now appear, O God, and humbly bid you, turn not our gracious face, away from me, poor sinner.

This sacred organ prelude was the final entry in Bach’s eighteen Chorale Preludes (BWV 651-668). Bach composed “Vor deinen Thron tret ich heirmit” in the style of the “fugue.” The fugue is a musical compositional technique, for the organ, in which the composer uses “voices,” established upon a dominant musical theme, and weaves them together, as one voice “follows” (“fugue” comes from the old French, based on the Latin fuga, to flee, give flight).[4] Thus, the composition is an instrumental chorale. Bach introduced a contrapuntal voice, a “counterpoint,” in which a primary voice is established in his “subject” (the main theme of the Fugue, which is revealed in the opening), with the alternate “voices,” the “contrapuntal” voices, following.[5] The organ’s chorale in three-part imitative accompaniment, then, moves to a connecting passage, or “episode.” The counterpoint voice is brought into full polyphonic harmony in the conclusion, the “Coda.” Through it all, the cantus firmus (“fixed song”), is a Gregorian chant used as the primary musical phrase.

How very fitting that as Bach prepares to enter eternity he writes a Prelude. The Prelude is a glorious introduction to an eternity in which divergent parts of life, like the several voices of the organ, are, at last, brought together. As music theorist, David Yearsley, wrote:

“Bach’s last piece is an elaborate demonstration of intricate contrapuntal technique used to treat a chorale text which both anticipates death and refers beyond it, to the arrival of the dead man in heaven.”[6]

Fragments of Life

Dietrich Bonhoeffer referred to Bach as he lay imprisoned at Flossenbürg Prison. The great martyr-of-the faith was reflecting on the “fragments” of one’s life that seems to lose meaning in the course of time. Yet, he finds that those fragments take on new meaning when seen in light of a God-redeemed world. He wrote,

“It finally comes to this, if one thinks about the fragment of our life, how the whole was really planned and thought out, and of what material it consists. There are finally fragments which still belong to the rubbish heap, and there are those fragments which are meaningful only when looked at in the perspective of centuries because their fulfillment can be only a divine matter, fragments which must remain fragments.”

Bonhoeffer, then, refers to the fugue:

“An analogy that comes to mind is the fugue. If our life also is only a slightest reflection of such a fragment, in which at least for a short while the various themes, growing ever stronger, harmonize, and in which the great counterpoint is held on to from beginning to end so that finally, after the breaking-off point, the chorale ‘Vor deined Thron tret ich hiermit’ can still be intoned, then we do not wish to complain about our fragmentary life, but even to be glad for it.”[7]

Bach enters heaven with a Prelude composition. Bonhoeffer faces martyrdom with a fugue analogy playing in his mind; the fragmented voices of life, then, coming together into a harmonious meaning. Thus, we recall the truth of the Scripture:

“And we know that all things work together for good to them that love God, to them who are the called according to his purpose (Romans 8:28 King James Bible “Authorized Version”).

The Fugue of Life


Our lives are a fugue. We look back and see the fragments of life, at first-glance futile and independent of any apparent main theme of life, at length, coming together, under God’s sovereign supervision, to make a whole. Even our pain, discordant as pain is, moves, finally, to somehow “imitate” the main theme, “to glorify God and enjoying Him forever.” We live and we shall die, but the fragments of our lives do not die. Singularities of life unite in a unity of life through the composing intentions of Jesus Christ. And life has meaning beyond what we could have ever imagined. Or, as C.S. Lewis wrote,

“And, for this is the end of all the stories, and we can most truly say that they all lived happily ever after. But, for them, it was only the beginning of the real story. All their life in this world and all their adventures in Narnia had only been the cover, and the title page: now at last they were beginning Chapter One of the Great Story which no one on Earth has read: which goes on forever: in which every chapter is better than the one before.”[8]

Your life, then, is, in Christ, a chorale and a prelude to a larger symphony that waits. Think on these things as the organist plays the Prelude to Divine Services this next Lord’s Day. All of that devotion spent for one liturgical musical piece? Bach must have thought he was composing for God.

[1] David Yearsley, “Bach’s Deathbed Chorale,” CounterPunch: Tells the Facts, Names the Names, October 14, 2011, “Final Notes,” accessed October 15, 2014,

[2] Christoph Wolff, Johann Sebastian Bach: The Learned Musician (New York: W.W. Norton, 2001).

[3] “Über dieser Fuge, wo der Name B A C H im Contrasubject angebracht worden, ist der Verfasser gestorben.” (“At the point where the composer introduces the name BACH [for which the English notation would be B♭–A–C–B♮] in the countersubject to this fugue, the composer died.”). See Wolff, Johann Sebastian Bach.

[4] See “Definition of Fugue in English:,” Fugue: Definition of Fugue in Oxford Dictionary (British & World English), accessed October 15, 2014,

[5] David Gaynor. Yearsley, Bach and the Meanings of Counterpoint (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002).

[6] David Yearsley, “Bach’s Deathbed Chorale,” CounterPunch: Tells the Facts, Names the Names, October 14, 2011, “Final Notes,” accessed October 15, 2014,

[7] This is from a letter of 21 February 1944. This translation is from Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Psalms: The Prayer Book of the Bible With a Sketch on the Life of Dietrich Bonhoeffer (Minneapolis: Augsburg Publishing House, 1970), 85-86.

[8] C. S. Lewis, “Chapter Sixteen: Farewell to Shadowlands,” in The Chronicles of Narnia Vol 7 The Last Battle (New York: HarperCollins, 2002), 228ff.

The Wounded Parson: Pastoral Self-Knowledge and Self-Care through Vocational Renewal in the Gospel

1930s Old Family Photo

There is an Anglican bishop who concludes his interviews with candidates for Holy Orders by asking himself, “Is this a whole person seeking to express his wholeness through the ministry, or is this a person trying to find his wholeness in the ministry?”[1] Good question. As pastors, the unconscious agendas of a painful family-of-origin experience become […]

Continue reading...

Prayer for Mission

Morning Prayer

When my soul is weary with woe I turn there to give unfettered song to my endentured spirit. When I find that my fretful thoughts are wound too tightly with the world I turn there to set loose my sentences with sentences more devoutly composed. When I long for comfort, for confession; and when I […]

Continue reading...

Regarding Marriage


Alfred Austin (1835-1914), the Poet Laureate of England, who followed Alfred, Lord Tennyson, wrote, “Creeds were to them but chains to break; No formulas their thirst could slake.”[1] There are many, today, who see “creeds and theological formulae” scattered, broken in pieces on the steps of courthouses through the land as the highest courts preferred the apparant […]

Continue reading...

Prayers in a Time of War


Prayer is, always, most effectual as it rises, formed in fervency, from the burdened spirit of a “righteous man” (James 5:16). The “righteous” believer is one who is “in Christ;” covered by His perfect life and faithfully following God’s revealed will through the guidance of the Holy Spirit. Yet, there are times, seasons of life, […]

Continue reading...

Bonhoeffer, Creation, and the Psalms

Théo (Théophile) van Rysselberghe (23 November 1862 – 14 December 1926), La Vigne en octobre, 1912.

The Lord surely knew that I needed a divine cordial to eniven my step this day. Sometimes we need to see beyond the presenting images of life to find the transcendant. When we locate that signpost and read it clearly, given faith to follow its direction, and begin to walk towards its destination we come to live […]

Continue reading...

Speaking with Conviction

I have been thinking about classes in training seminarians in public speaking. This is different than teaching homiletics, or preaching (or sacred communication, as the Army calls it). Public speaking involves the classical rhetorical features (Aristotle’s three forms of persuasion: logos, pathos, and ethos) that can be boiled down to “style/skill” and “substance.” I hope […]

Continue reading...

And So We Must Pray

imageContinue reading...

How to Begin Anything

Leonardo da Vinci, "Study of Proportion," c.1490. Royal Collection, Windsor Castle, London, UK.

It is a new school year. Teachers and university professors all over the United States, Canada, Great Britain, and the Western European nations, to name only a few, are beginning a new semester. I love beginnings. Therefore, I really enjoyed a new semester. There is nothing like getting to know new students, laying out the […]

Continue reading...

Preaching on Mission (Matthew 4:12 – 17): Keynote Message at the National Conference on Preaching

Celtic Cross Wales

  There has never been a more important time to talk to preachers about preaching on mission. The landscape of Old Christendom is like an abandoned strip mine, with huge, gaping, ugly craters, filling now with the most horrid debris and litter. These strip mines were once verdant pastures and lovely hills of Western Civilization, where […]

Continue reading...